USA: Which Justices Voted to Hear DOMA, Prop 8 Cases?

Written by scott on December 13th, 2012

USA: Which Justices Voted to Hear DOMA, Prop 8 Cases?Andrew Koppelman suspects it was the conservatives:

My guess is that the court agreed to hear the California case because the four conservative members — Antonin Scalia, Clarence Thomas, Samuel Alito and Chief Justice John Roberts — hoped to overrule the lower court’s decision that the state had to recognize such marriages.

It only takes four votes to put a case on the court’s docket, and they may be hoping that they can win Kennedy’s vote, while discounting the danger that he will go the other way. This would be a sensible call, since it is far from clear that any of the liberal members of the court are now willing to hold that same-sex couples have a right to marry.

Yet Kennedy could foil this strategy by declining, in the end, to review the case. Four votes are all it takes to hear a case, but five votes are sufficient to then dismiss that decision as improvidently granted.

Authored By Andrew Sullivan – See the Full Story at The Daily Beast

Find more articles and gay wedding resources.

To subscribe to this blog, use the rss feed on the right, or use the form at right to join our email list. You can also email us at Or find us on Facebook. We’re also tweeting daily at


Leave a Comment